Discussion Topic | Replies (estimated) | Archive Link |
Untitled | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Untitled |
The Adventure of ... | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#The Adventure of ... |
Sherlock Holmes Topics Box | 4 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Sherlock Holmes Topics Box |
Few more books... | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Few more books... |
Changes in Holmes' Character | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Changes in Holmes' Character |
Basil Rathbone | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Basil Rathbone |
YOURE WRONG | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#YOURE WRONG |
Turtle stuff | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Turtle stuff |
Credit due | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Credit due |
Mycroft Wolfe? | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Mycroft Wolfe? |
The truth is out there | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#The truth is out there |
"Sherlockian" | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#"Sherlockian" |
Clean-up | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Clean-up |
Why is there so much dying in the "Sherlock" stories? | 6 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Why is there so much dying in the "Sherlock" stories? |
Page Split | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Page Split |
Conan the Grammarian | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Conan the Grammarian |
Question | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Question |
Jack the Ripper | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Jack the Ripper |
Nazi spinoffs | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Nazi spinoffs |
Question | 9 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Question 2 |
Holmesian deduction | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Holmesian deduction |
Good Article nomination has failed | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Good Article nomination has failed |
Sherlock as a reflection of vistorian attitudes | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Sherlock as a reflection of vistorian attitudes |
No Shit, Sherlock | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#No Shit, Sherlock |
Public Domain Status | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Public Domain Status |
Overlinking story/novel titles | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Overlinking story/novel titles |
Holmes' and Watson's ages | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Holmes' and Watson's ages |
Quotations | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Quotations |
Questions about titles | 8 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Questions about titles |
Copyright | 4 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Copyright |
Mustache? | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Mustache? |
The Exploits of Sherlock Holmes | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#The Exploits of Sherlock Holmes |
Bold and redlinks | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Bold and redlinks |
Where should this be put? | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Where should this be put? |
Insult | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Insult |
Museum | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Museum |
Drug Addiction | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Drug Addiction |
Shanghai Knights? | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Shanghai Knights? |
The Beekeeper's Apprentice | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#The Beekeeper's Apprentice |
Back to basics? | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Back to basics? |
Disguises | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Disguises |
Extlink cleanup | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Extlink cleanup |
Spoiler alerts? | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Spoiler alerts? |
Edits to Women Section | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Edits to Women Section |
Fair use rationale for Image:Jeremy Brett.jpg | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Fair use rationale for Image:Jeremy Brett.jpg |
My attempts to improve readability | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#My attempts to improve readability |
Featured Article Candidate? | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Featured Article Candidate? |
Splitting the article | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Splitting the article |
Sherlockian speculation in midst of article | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Sherlockian speculation in midst of article |
Link debate | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Link debate |
Deductive reasoning | 9 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Deductive reasoning |
StarTrekian Universe Problems | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#StarTrekian Universe Problems |
"occasional user of cocaine and morphine" | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#"occasional user of cocaine and morphine" |
Victorian ethics | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Victorian ethics |
Doyle | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 1#Doyle |
Problem with breaking out "fictional character" | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Problem with breaking out "fictional character" |
Citation needed | 4 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Citation needed |
OK, this might not be encylopedia material, but it's both funny and disturbing. | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#OK, this might not be encylopedia material, but it's both funny and disturbing. |
Sherlock Holmes WikiProject? | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Sherlock Holmes WikiProject? |
Info | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Info |
An addition to the works by other authors section | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#An addition to the works by other authors section |
Readability | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Readability |
Reworking | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Reworking |
Why sentence(s) removed | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Why sentence(s) removed |
Fashion | 4 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Fashion |
Rent | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Rent |
Holme's sister | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Holme's sister |
Works by other authors | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Works by other authors |
Editing the refs | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Editing the refs |
Major edit | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Major edit |
Copyright Expiry | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Copyright Expiry |
Spoof in Which Watson wins! | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Spoof in Which Watson wins! |
Mycroft | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Mycroft |
Image copyright problem with Image:Fourthdoctorwengchiang.jpg | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Image copyright problem with Image:Fourthdoctorwengchiang.jpg |
Son of Arthur Conan Doyle? | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Son of Arthur Conan Doyle? |
Use of Weapons | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Use of Weapons |
"Holmes and his Woman" | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#"Holmes and his Woman" |
Vandalism | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Vandalism |
Date of Holmes' birth | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Date of Holmes' birth |
About him not using a Calabash pipe | 5 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#About him not using a Calabash pipe |
"reconsider use of 'canon'" | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#"reconsider use of 'canon'" |
Re-edit | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Re-edit |
Racism | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Racism |
Physical Strength | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Physical Strength |
Sources | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Sources |
Forensics | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Forensics |
"is an ass" | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#"is an ass" |
Holmes in Hades | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Holmes in Hades |
The Revolver used by Holmes | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#The Revolver used by Holmes |
Mental Illness | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Mental Illness |
Article covers both Conan Doyle's writings and his Sherlock Holmes character | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Article covers both Conan Doyle's writings and his Sherlock Holmes character |
Where is Edgar Allen Poe's Dupin? | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Where is Edgar Allen Poe's Dupin? |
British English | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#British English |
Watson's grandchildren | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Watson's grandchildren |
Addition to "See also" section. | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Addition to "See also" section. |
Cut Other "Holmes-esque" fictional detectives section | 9 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Cut Other "Holmes-esque" fictional detectives section |
Personal Hygiene | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Personal Hygiene |
Mary Sue | 4 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Mary Sue |
'The Game' and Doctor Watson | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#'The Game' and Doctor Watson |
Updated with newest movie? No..but why? (Also, Holmes & Watson in a Fred Saberhagen book) | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Updated with newest movie? No..but why? (Also, Holmes & Watson in a Fred Saberhagen book) |
Move over all adaptations | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Move over all adaptations |
Derived Works | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Derived Works |
Incorrect Date Of Anthony Horowitz's Holmes Novel Announcement | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Incorrect Date Of Anthony Horowitz's Holmes Novel Announcement |
Theorizing about origin of name | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Theorizing about origin of name |
a missing point | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#a missing point |
Genius | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Genius |
Holmes's Parents | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Holmes's Parents |
Copyright | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Copyright |
2011 Spanish Film | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#2011 Spanish Film |
Too long! | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Too long! |
Edit request on 31 December 2011 | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Edit request on 31 December 2011 |
Edit request on 31 December 2011 | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Edit request on 31 December 2011 2 |
Edit request on 1 January 2012 | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Edit request on 1 January 2012 |
Reference not mentioned on this page | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Reference not mentioned on this page |
A new derivative - pop culture reference | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#A new derivative - pop culture reference |
Drug usage | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Drug usage |
Edit request on 25 February 2012 | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Edit request on 25 February 2012 |
Edit request on 13 March 2012 | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Edit request on 13 March 2012 |
Introductory paragraph | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Introductory paragraph |
Holmes' age | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Holmes' age |
intro para cont. | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#intro para cont. |
Criticism | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Criticism |
In-Universe | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#In-Universe |
RV Of Television Edits, 11/02/12 | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#RV Of Television Edits, 11/02/12 |
Holmes' alleged use of phrenology | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Holmes' alleged use of phrenology |
Sherlock | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Sherlock |
Sherlock's age | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Sherlock's age |
Adler Edits, 12/12 | 8 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Adler Edits, 12/12 |
Original Research in Holmesian Deduction | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Original Research in Holmesian Deduction |
Edit request on 24 January 2013 | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Edit request on 24 January 2013 |
Detective Conan | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Detective Conan |
Edit request on 31 March 2013 | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Edit request on 31 March 2013 |
adding a pistol in weapons section | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#adding a pistol in weapons section |
Sidney Paget: Sherlock Holmes image | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Sidney Paget: Sherlock Holmes image |
grammatical error | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#grammatical error |
Edit "Elementary, my dear Watson" | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Edit "Elementary, my dear Watson" |
Books written by Sherlock | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Books written by Sherlock |
Image Error? | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Image Error? |
Copyright news | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 2#Copyright news |
Semi-protected edit request on 7 January 2014 | 11 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on 7 January 2014 |
Moving Related and derivative works to non-canonical Sherlock Holmes works | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Moving Related and derivative works to non-canonical Sherlock Holmes works |
Sourcing of Forensic science subsection | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Sourcing of Forensic science subsection |
Please Add... | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Please Add... |
Abductive reasoning is not the same as modus ponens | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Abductive reasoning is not the same as modus ponens |
Henry Cauvain's "Maximilien Heller" | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Henry Cauvain's "Maximilien Heller" |
Not a Gentleman ? | 6 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Not a Gentleman ? |
"Elementary, my dear Watson" | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#"Elementary, my dear Watson" |
Holmes' age | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Holmes' age |
Semi-protected edit request on 21 May 2014 | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on 21 May 2014 |
New NEWS today, for future editing | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#New NEWS today, for future editing |
Plan | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Plan |
Why is Matt Frewer not mentioned as having portrayed Sherlock Holmes on this page...? | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Why is Matt Frewer not mentioned as having portrayed Sherlock Holmes on this page...? |
Almost GAN time (again)? | 11 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Almost GAN time (again)? |
Latest changes | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Latest changes |
What is the purpose of this bracketed entry? | 5 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#What is the purpose of this bracketed entry? |
Feedback to improve this article | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Feedback to improve this article |
External links modified | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#External links modified |
Semi-protected edit request on 24 October 2015 | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on 24 October 2015 |
Lead Editing | 5 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Lead Editing |
Adaptations Mess | 4 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Adaptations Mess |
Elementary My Dear Watson | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Elementary My Dear Watson |
Weak grammar and probable typo | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Weak grammar and probable typo |
Semi-protected edit request on 6 May 2016 | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on 6 May 2016 |
Holmes' age | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Holmes' age 2 |
Elementary, my dear Watson | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Elementary, my dear Watson |
Cricketers as origin of name | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Cricketers as origin of name |
External links modified | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#External links modified 2 |
Adding the Spy Elements in Sherlock Holmes story | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Adding the Spy Elements in Sherlock Holmes story |
Link to Mindfulness | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Link to Mindfulness |
External links modified | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#External links modified 3 |
A photo of the Soviet actor Vasily Livanov. | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#A photo of the Soviet actor Vasily Livanov. |
Story dating | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Story dating |
Semi-protected edit request on 5 October 2018 | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on 5 October 2018 |
Sherlock Holmes / David Burke | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Sherlock Holmes / David Burke |
Elementary | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Elementary |
Correction to Copyright info | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Correction to Copyright info |
Cite Standardization | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Cite Standardization |
Contemporary popularity of Doyle's work? | 4 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Contemporary popularity of Doyle's work? |
Removal of line about the estates legal proceedings | 4 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Removal of line about the estates legal proceedings |
Semi-protected edit request on 29 November 2020 | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on 29 November 2020 |
"well-known" | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#"well-known" |
"Postcolonial Criticism" Section | 5 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#"Postcolonial Criticism" Section |
"Elementary, my dear Watson" Appeared Much Earlier | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#"Elementary, my dear Watson" Appeared Much Earlier |
Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment |
Semi-protected edit request on 27 January 2022 | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Semi-protected edit request on 27 January 2022 |
Which story is non-Victorian/Edwardian? | 7 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Which story is non-Victorian/Edwardian? |
Radio adaptations of Sherlock Holmes missing | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Radio adaptations of Sherlock Holmes missing |
Sherlock Holmes movies and facts | 3 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#Sherlock Holmes movies and facts |
"Elementary My Dear Watson" Section Is Outdated | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes/Archive 3#"Elementary My Dear Watson" Section Is Outdated |
Arguably the best known?? | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes#Arguably the best known?? |
proposed edit, under 'Personal Combat' | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes#proposed edit, under 'Personal Combat' |
Indonesian translation notes | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes#Indonesian translation notes |
Redirect | 2 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes#Redirect |
Early versions of his name | 1 | Talk:Sherlock Holmes#Early versions of his name |