Discussion Topic | Replies (estimated) | Archive Link |
The mainstream scientific view of the origins of SARS-CoV-2 | 14 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 1#The mainstream scientific view of the origins of SARS-CoV-2 |
Origin Scenarios | 14 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 1#Origin Scenarios |
POVFORK | 7 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 1#POVFORK |
Interesting sources and drama | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 1#Interesting sources and drama |
Pangolins | 5 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 1#Pangolins |
Major POV problems | 15 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 1#Major POV problems |
WP:MEDRS | 12 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 1#WP:MEDRS |
CNET | 10 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 1#CNET |
Scope and subject of this article | 44 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 2#Scope and subject of this article |
Content removal | 14 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 1#Content removal |
Wrong title | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 1#Wrong title |
U.S. government investigations | 17 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 1#U.S. government investigations |
Fresh new RS sources | 23 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 1#Fresh new RS sources |
Preliminary WHO results | 7 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 1#Preliminary WHO results |
Due weight of Frozen food hypothesis? | 20 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 1#Due weight of Frozen food hypothesis? |
Biden Administration "deep concerns" about WHO report handling | 8 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 1#Biden Administration "deep concerns" about WHO report handling |
Why shouldn't more recent facts be added? | 44 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 2#Why shouldn't more recent facts be added? |
Inclusion of a quote from a MEDRS | 23 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 2#Inclusion of a quote from a MEDRS |
Visa delays | 9 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 2#Visa delays |
Article should mention the WHO's history of supporting Chinese statements right up front | 45 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 3#Article should mention the WHO's history of supporting Chinese statements right up front |
Misleading intro | 16 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 2#Misleading intro |
Professionalization of the article | 9 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 2#Professionalization of the article |
Origin of virus | 13 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 3#Origin of virus |
WHO not unanimous and other intro issues | 25 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 3#WHO not unanimous and other intro issues |
This article is propaganda | 6 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 2#This article is propaganda |
New WHO Report | 15 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 2#New WHO Report |
Scientific consensus on origins | 6 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 2#Scientific consensus on origins |
Another new investigation | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 3#Another new investigation |
WHO "report was subject to political pressure" | 9 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 3#WHO "report was subject to political pressure" |
New article by Zhi | 4 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 3#New article by Zhi |
Nicholas Wade journalistic investigation on the emergence of Covid calls attention on Andersen (2020) flaws | 5 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 3#Nicholas Wade journalistic investigation on the emergence of Covid calls attention on Andersen (2020) flaws |
The New York Times | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 3#The New York Times |
Wuhan lab leak section | 62 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 3#Wuhan lab leak section |
evidence for natural emergence | 5 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 3#evidence for natural emergence |
re: the Nicholas Wade discussion earlier | 19 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 3#re: the Nicholas Wade discussion earlier |
Origins of SARS-CoV-2 | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 3#Origins of SARS-CoV-2 |
Letter in Science calls for investigation of theory | 22 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 3#Letter in Science calls for investigation of theory |
Science claims lableak is not conspiracy theory | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 3#Science claims lableak is not conspiracy theory |
Worth considerng? | 5 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 3#Worth considerng? |
CDC Director testifies: "Certainly a lab-based origin is one possibility." | 5 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 3#CDC Director testifies: "Certainly a lab-based origin is one possibility." |
Undisclosed Wuhan lab workers sickened in Nov 2019? | 17 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#Undisclosed Wuhan lab workers sickened in Nov 2019? |
A questionable consensus | 40 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 5#A questionable consensus |
Inclusion of seroprevalence studies | 9 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 3#Inclusion of seroprevalence studies |
Dr. Anthony Fauci states he is "not convinced" about natural origins hypothesis for SARS-CoV-2 | 13 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#Dr. Anthony Fauci states he is "not convinced" about natural origins hypothesis for SARS-CoV-2 |
Discussion at WikiProject COVID-19 | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#Discussion at WikiProject COVID-19 |
A bizarre lack of information regarding the lab leak theory | 11 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#A bizarre lack of information regarding the lab leak theory |
Facebook Ends Ban on Posts Asserting Covid-19 Was Man-Made | 17 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#Facebook Ends Ban on Posts Asserting Covid-19 Was Man-Made |
links to other articles on lab leak | 5 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#links to other articles on lab leak |
"Lab leak" listed at Redirects for discussion | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#"Lab leak" listed at Redirects for discussion |
Why declare a "consensus" on the origin, given that all options are still open | 131 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 6#Why declare a "consensus" on the origin, given that all options are still open |
Using curated information from news sources in Investigations into the origin of COVID-19 | 7 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#Using curated information from news sources in Investigations into the origin of COVID-19 |
Questions about references 1 and 2, general disinterest of authors | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#Questions about references 1 and 2, general disinterest of authors |
Delete sections transcluded from Severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 | 25 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 5#Delete sections transcluded from Severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 2 |
Media coverage section | 9 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#Media coverage section |
Recent news (06/06/2021) worth considering? | 25 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 5#Recent news (06/06/2021) worth considering? |
Broken list-defined citations | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#Broken list-defined citations |
Malicious leak? | 5 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#Malicious leak? |
Daszak conflict of interest | 7 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#Daszak conflict of interest |
"U.S. Report Found It Plausible Covid-19 Leaked From Wuhan Lab" | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#"U.S. Report Found It Plausible Covid-19 Leaked From Wuhan Lab" |
Nature: "The COVID lab-leak hypothesis: what scientists do and don’t know" | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#Nature: "The COVID lab-leak hypothesis: what scientists do and don’t know" |
Mention in the lede that the joing WHO-China investigation has been criticized by other countries. | 6 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#Mention in the lede that the joing WHO-China investigation has been criticized by other countries. |
the current "Laboratory incident" section is crap | 7 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 5#the current "Laboratory incident" section is crap |
Administrator Noticeboard request for talk page protection | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#Administrator Noticeboard request for talk page protection |
Fanatically shoving the zoonotic origin as if it is the forgone scientific consensus | 20 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 5#Fanatically shoving the zoonotic origin as if it is the forgone scientific consensus |
Classified report with early support for lab leak theory reemerges as focal point for lawmakers digging into Covid-19 origins | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#Classified report with early support for lab leak theory reemerges as focal point for lawmakers digging into Covid-19 origins |
"experts at the time" and highly biased treatment of WHO report reception | 7 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#"experts at the time" and highly biased treatment of WHO report reception |
"Proposed explanations" section is highly imbalanced | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#"Proposed explanations" section is highly imbalanced |
Rename into "Investigations into the origin of SARS-CoV-2" | 8 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 5#Rename into "Investigations into the origin of SARS-CoV-2" |
Joint-WHO-China investigation, keep its official and accurate name | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#Joint-WHO-China investigation, keep its official and accurate name |
Leading biologist dampens his ‘smoking gun’ Covid lab leak theory | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#Leading biologist dampens his ‘smoking gun’ Covid lab leak theory |
EU joins Biden’s call for fresh probe into coronavirus origins | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#EU joins Biden’s call for fresh probe into coronavirus origins |
Background reading regarding potential zoonotic spillover | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 5#Background reading regarding potential zoonotic spillover |
Guardian quote | 9 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#Guardian quote |
Related Draft | 3 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#Related Draft |
Biden remarks at G7 | 6 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 5#Biden remarks at G7 |
David Asher, should we even have this quote? | 4 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 4#David Asher, should we even have this quote? |
Revert on added WSJ article to lab leak section | 17 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 5#Revert on added WSJ article to lab leak section |
"deliberate bioengineering of the virus has been ruled out" | 89 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 8#"deliberate bioengineering of the virus has been ruled out" |
Chinese government investigations | 3 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 5#Chinese government investigations |
See also | 3 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 5#See also |
"Consensus among virologists" | 12 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 5#"Consensus among virologists" |
Two kinds of laboratory leak? Confusion of terms | 12 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 6#Two kinds of laboratory leak? Confusion of terms |
Pointy edits re: Lab leak | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 5#Pointy edits re: Lab leak |
Related discussion at WP:MFD | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 5#Related discussion at WP:MFD |
Early Chinese Virus sequencing deleted | 36 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 7#Early Chinese Virus sequencing deleted |
The wording for the WHO-China joint report | 85 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 9#The wording for the WHO-China joint report |
Orphaned references in Investigations into the origin of COVID-19 | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 5#Orphaned references in Investigations into the origin of COVID-19 |
We made the news! | 11 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 6#We made the news! |
RfC: How should we refer to the report on SARS-COV-2 origins? | 24 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 7#RfC: How should we refer to the report on SARS-COV-2 origins? |
why the Bloom lab preprint doesn't make the lab leak more likely | 115 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 10#why the Bloom lab preprint doesn't make the lab leak more likely |
Cnet article | 7 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 8#Cnet article |
Last foreign scientist | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 6#Last foreign scientist |
Military connections of Wuhan lab scientists? | 16 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 7#Military connections of Wuhan lab scientists? |
Citing Shi Zheng-Li for the origin of COVID-19. | 28 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 7#Citing Shi Zheng-Li for the origin of COVID-19. |
Removal of the phrase "conspiracy theories" from the lede | 17 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 8#Removal of the phrase "conspiracy theories" from the lede |
New Republic Article from June 29 | 8 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 7#New Republic Article from June 29 |
Related discussion about reliability of a podcast | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 7#Related discussion about reliability of a podcast |
Daszak in lede | 3 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 5#Daszak in lede |
Closure from the RFC on MEDRS vs RS | 3 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 8#Closure from the RFC on MEDRS vs RS |
Talk page consensus on high-quality "Lab Leak" sources | 18 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 8#Talk page consensus on high-quality "Lab Leak" sources |
Re: Gain-of-function research | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 7#Re: Gain-of-function research |
New Lancet letter | 15 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 9#New Lancet letter |
Centralized discussion on MEDRS vs NEWSORG on the origin of SARS-CoV-2 | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 8#Centralized discussion on MEDRS vs NEWSORG on the origin of SARS-CoV-2 |
Lancet Commission task force | 4 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 8#Lancet Commission task force |
WHO report reception - in the Lead | 6 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 8#WHO report reception - in the Lead |
Covid origins: Australia’s role in the feedback loop promoting the Wuhan lab leak theory | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 8#Covid origins: Australia’s role in the feedback loop promoting the Wuhan lab leak theory |
WHO Director-General's opening remarks at the Member State Information Session on Origins | 5 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 10#WHO Director-General's opening remarks at the Member State Information Session on Origins |
"Reactions" section reverses scientific consensus | 12 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 9#"Reactions" section reverses scientific consensus |
What We Know About the Origins of COVID-19 | 17 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 8#What We Know About the Origins of COVID-19 |
Lab leak theory sources | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19#Lab leak theory sources |
Calls to investigate a laboratory leak reached a "fever pitch," fueling antipathy towards people of Asian ancestry | 9 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 8#Calls to investigate a laboratory leak reached a "fever pitch," fueling antipathy towards people of Asian ancestry |
Changing stance of experts regarding possible lab leak | 12 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 10#Changing stance of experts regarding possible lab leak |
WHO Report and Responses in Lead | 3 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 9#WHO Report and Responses in Lead |
Broken citation in lead | 3 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 10#Broken citation in lead |
We should not use Global Times as a source | 8 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 10#We should not use Global Times as a source |
Reactions to the Phase 1 WHO report - again | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 10#Reactions to the Phase 1 WHO report - again |
Recent review article | 4 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 10#Recent review article |
Zoonotic origin & lab-leak overlap | 15 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#Zoonotic origin & lab-leak overlap |
Can someone correct the reference to my article? | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 10#Can someone correct the reference to my article? |
Worthy earlier studies - and more? | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#Worthy earlier studies - and more? |
Candidate species to be intermediate hosts and amphibians | 3 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#Candidate species to be intermediate hosts and amphibians |
Bloom's preprint has been published | 4 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#Bloom's preprint has been published |
Suggestion to discuss the "Unclassified Summary of Assessment on COVID-19 Origins | 15 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#Suggestion to discuss the "Unclassified Summary of Assessment on COVID-19 Origins |
Distance between wet market and the Chinese CDC | 6 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#Distance between wet market and the Chinese CDC |
Reliable Source Noticeboard thread on Segreto and Deigin (2020) in BioEssays | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#Reliable Source Noticeboard thread on Segreto and Deigin (2020) in BioEssays |
Merge from COVID-19 misinformation § Virus origin hypotheses, or split to a new article | 4 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#Merge from COVID-19 misinformation § Virus origin hypotheses, or split to a new article |
"Lab Leak" Covid Origin Becomes Curioser? | 3 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#"Lab Leak" Covid Origin Becomes Curioser? |
More viruses that are even closer to SARS-CoV-2 discovered in bats | 5 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#More viruses that are even closer to SARS-CoV-2 discovered in bats |
Transition of "WHO Convened Study" to "SAGO" | 23 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#Transition of "WHO Convened Study" to "SAGO" |
Disbandedment of The Lancet COVID-19 Commission task force | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#Disbandedment of The Lancet COVID-19 Commission task force |
Winnipeg lab virus theft to Wuhan Institute of Virology | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#Winnipeg lab virus theft to Wuhan Institute of Virology |
New commentary piece in Science | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#New commentary piece in Science |
The Lancet Editor re Covid Origin Conflict of Interest | 4 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#The Lancet Editor re Covid Origin Conflict of Interest |
RfC at Talk:COVID-19 lab leak theory | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#RfC at Talk:COVID-19 lab leak theory |
WP:WIKIVOICE | 25 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#WP:WIKIVOICE |
"Less likely" | 11 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#"Less likely" |
Recent related news worth considering? | 4 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#Recent related news worth considering? |
New valuable sources (Nature, Science, Zenodo) to add to this page | 4 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#New valuable sources (Nature, Science, Zenodo) to add to this page |
Gain-of-function research at WIV | 12 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#Gain-of-function research at WIV |
Several including many | 3 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 11#Several including many |
New article of the Lancet Commission on lessons for the future from the COVID-19 pandemic | 43 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 12#New article of the Lancet Commission on lessons for the future from the COVID-19 pandemic |
Lancet Commission Statment | 20 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 12#Lancet Commission Statment |
I still think this source is worthy of more people taking a deeper look into | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 12#I still think this source is worthy of more people taking a deeper look into |
lead | 8 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 12#lead |
RfC on first paragraph | 81 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 12#RfC on first paragraph |
Lab Leak Theory Racism | 3 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 12#Lab Leak Theory Racism |
scientific background | 15 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 12#scientific background |
WSJ report of lab leak origin | 8 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 12#WSJ report of lab leak origin |
Weird how IPs are now allowed to make comments to the talkpage | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 12#Weird how IPs are now allowed to make comments to the talkpage |
Covid-19 likely resulted from lab leak | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 12#Covid-19 likely resulted from lab leak |
"Say" or "Speculate" | 37 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 13#"Say" or "Speculate" |
Most scientists agree ... | 4 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 12#Most scientists agree ... |
Academic source authored by Chinese nationals | 18 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 13#Academic source authored by Chinese nationals |
Section headings on this talk page re: CCP | 3 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 13#Section headings on this talk page re: CCP |
Outdated | 4 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 13#Outdated |
Adjusting the distance measurement from Wuhan to RATG13 sample location | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 13#Adjusting the distance measurement from Wuhan to RATG13 sample location |
Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 22 May 2023 | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 13#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 22 May 2023 |
Requested move 11 July 2023 | 13 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 13#Requested move 11 July 2023 |
Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 13 July 2023 | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 13#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 13 July 2023 |
Extended-confirmed-protected edit request : acknowledging the lab-leak evidence | 4 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 13#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request : acknowledging the lab-leak evidence |
Related NYT (7/26/2023) article worth adding? | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 13#Related NYT (7/26/2023) article worth adding? |
Lab Leak Most Likely Origin of Covid-19 Pandemic, Energy Department Now Says | 18 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 13#Lab Leak Most Likely Origin of Covid-19 Pandemic, Energy Department Now Says |
Article name | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 13#Article name |
Talk:COVID-19 lab leak theory#Request for comment | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 13#Talk:COVID-19 lab leak theory#Request for comment |
COVID-19 zoonosis theories | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 13#COVID-19 zoonosis theories |
Proposed merge of Zoonotic origins of COVID-19 into Origin of COVID-19 | 11 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19#Proposed merge of Zoonotic origins of COVID-19 into Origin of COVID-19 |
Key citation flawed? | 8 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 13#Key citation flawed? |
Arbitration Enforcement Request | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 13#Arbitration Enforcement Request |
Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 29 November 2023 | 6 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 13#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 29 November 2023 |
Origin theory: globally dormant virus | 3 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 13#Origin theory: globally dormant virus |
Treeshrews source is not accurate | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19#Treeshrews source is not accurate |
Zoonotic origins of COVID-19 | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19/Archive 13#Zoonotic origins of COVID-19 |
risk assessment | 1 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19#risk assessment |
Rename page to Origin of SARS-CoV-2 ? | 2 | Talk:Origin of COVID-19#Rename page to Origin of SARS-CoV-2 ? |