Discussion Topic | Replies (estimated) | Archive Link |
Newspaper Horoscopes | 21 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Newspaper Horoscopes |
Is Astrology a Science? | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Is Astrology a Science? |
Attribution is not innuendo | 55 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Attribution is not innuendo |
Discourse | 12 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Discourse |
Attribution is not innuendo | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Attribution is not innuendo |
Attribution is not innuendo | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Attribution is not innuendo 2 |
Rewriting | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Rewriting |
Rewriting | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Rewriting 2 |
Galileo Galilei | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Galileo Galilei |
Notable astrologers | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Notable astrologers |
Astrology: Between Religion and the Empirical | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Astrology: Between Religion and the Empirical |
History of Astrology | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#History of Astrology |
PROOF for Isidore of Seville | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#PROOF for Isidore of Seville |
List of Astrologers | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#List of Astrologers |
Neo-Platonic astrology | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Neo-Platonic astrology |
Article is nearly 32K | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Article is nearly 32K |
unclear text | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#unclear text |
The case against Astrology - Distance + life prediction | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#The case against Astrology - Distance + life prediction |
The Planets | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#The Planets |
A Horoscope for Wikipedia | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#A Horoscope for Wikipedia |
Why I removed the "constellations of the zodiac and the parts of the body" section | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Why I removed the "constellations of the zodiac and the parts of the body" section |
Explanation of restored sections | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Explanation of restored sections |
What astrologers "don't know" about the span of each constellation | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#What astrologers "don't know" about the span of each constellation |
Rudolf Steiner | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Rudolf Steiner |
Numerology and Astrology | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Numerology and Astrology 2 |
Case for astrology? Text is very off-topic | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Case for astrology? Text is very off-topic |
Combining "Skeptics View..."/"Case Against..." Sections | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Combining "Skeptics View..."/"Case Against..." Sections |
History mini-section | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#History mini-section |
Re-directs | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Re-directs |
Astrofaces advertisement | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Astrofaces advertisement |
Categorization | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 1#Categorization |
Request for your aid dealing with actions from a user against Religious, Spiritual and Esoteric articles | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 2#Request for your aid dealing with actions from a user against Religious, Spiritual and Esoteric articles |
An Astrology Website | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 2#An Astrology Website |
How about the tenth planet? | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 2#How about the tenth planet? |
External links to Astrology Schools | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 2#External links to Astrology Schools |
External Link SPAM removal | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 2#External Link SPAM removal |
Astrology and days of the week | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 2#Astrology and days of the week |
Judicial astrology | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 2#Judicial astrology |
Issues with the Astrology article | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 2#Issues with the Astrology article |
Ptolemy | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 2#Ptolemy |
On Positive Discussion | 23 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 2#On Positive Discussion |
Astrology Page Edits | 19 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 3#Astrology Page Edits |
Age of Aquarius song | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 3#Age of Aquarius song |
RfC | 12 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 3#RfC |
Sourcing Wikipedia Astrology Page | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 3#Sourcing Wikipedia Astrology Page |
Providing Sources & References for Wiki-Astrology Page | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 3#Providing Sources & References for Wiki-Astrology Page |
cat and thoughts on intro | 16 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 3#cat and thoughts on intro |
Four classic elements image | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 3#Four classic elements image |
Western Bias | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 3#Western Bias |
References? | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 3#References? |
Review comments | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 3#Review comments |
Sorry to leap in... | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 3#Sorry to leap in... |
Intro length | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 3#Intro length |
Images | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 3#Images |
Changes | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 3#Changes |
Astrology: Threat or Menace? | 12 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 3#Astrology: Threat or Menace? |
Major revisions of the article | 15 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 4#Major revisions of the article |
Main image | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 4#Main image |
Superstition | 39 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 4#Superstition |
Miscellaneous | 12 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 4#Miscellaneous |
Astrology and the days of the week | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 4#Astrology and the days of the week |
Incorporate this info...? | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 4#Incorporate this info...? |
Seven Liberal Arts and Astrology | 11 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 4#Seven Liberal Arts and Astrology |
Falsifiablity | 69 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 4#Falsifiablity |
Why do we have links to nowhere? | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 4#Why do we have links to nowhere? |
Effects on world culture | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 4#Effects on world culture |
Not true | 12 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 5#Not true |
Twelve Holy Days | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 5#Twelve Holy Days |
Image overload? | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 5#Image overload? |
Objective validity of astrology | 57 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 5#Objective validity of astrology |
Criticism of astrology in the introduction | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 5#Criticism of astrology in the introduction |
Negative effects of astrology on society | 18 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 5#Negative effects of astrology on society |
A request | 18 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 5#A request |
Proposed section | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 5#Proposed section |
The intro | 34 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 5#The intro |
From the village pump | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 6#From the village pump |
Science and 'pseudoscience' | 17 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 6#Science and 'pseudoscience' |
Semi-protection | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 6#Semi-protection |
Evolution | 10 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 6#Evolution |
The most feared topic among astrologers | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 6#The most feared topic among astrologers |
Knowledge of astrology | 14 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 6#Knowledge of astrology |
Deletion of the Objective validity of astrology article | 32 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 7#Deletion of the Objective validity of astrology article |
Astrology as a science | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 6#Astrology as a science |
Astrology Wikiproject | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 6#Astrology Wikiproject |
NOR | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 6#NOR |
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Objective validity of astrology | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 6#Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Objective validity of astrology |
Intro to objective validity | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 6#Intro to objective validity |
Astrology and science | 29 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 6#Astrology and science |
Marskell's long-winded thoughts on sourcing | 11 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 6#Marskell's long-winded thoughts on sourcing |
by the way, astrolog? | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 6#by the way, astrolog? |
Astromancy & Astrology -- The Same Thing? | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 6#Astromancy & Astrology -- The Same Thing? |
Mars effect & Ertel | 36 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 6#Mars effect & Ertel |
Objective validity... | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 7#Objective validity... |
Sympathetic tone | 25 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 7#Sympathetic tone |
Clear consensus | 19 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 7#Clear consensus |
Categorization | 15 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 7#Categorization |
Humanist article | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 7#Humanist article |
National Science Foundation | 16 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 7#National Science Foundation |
Accusation of 3rr | 27 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 7#Accusation of 3rr |
Bickering | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Bickering |
Dispute resolution | 17 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Dispute resolution |
Protected | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Protected |
External Links | 22 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#External Links |
How to Get the Wiki-Astrology Page Back Online & Honest | 11 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#How to Get the Wiki-Astrology Page Back Online & Honest |
Reaching consensus | 32 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Reaching consensus |
Astrophysics research | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Astrophysics research |
Strange Hypothesis | 16 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Strange Hypothesis |
Points of contention | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Points of contention |
Pseudoscience (again) | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Pseudoscience (again) |
Ptolemy | 22 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Ptolemy |
Scientific POV | 25 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Scientific POV |
Getting the page unblocked | 12 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Getting the page unblocked |
How's this? | 17 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#How's this? |
Once it's unblocked, we might... | 19 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Once it's unblocked, we might... |
Astrology & Science (My rewrite) | 25 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Astrology & Science (My rewrite) |
Reliable sources | 11 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Reliable sources |
The Obvious 'Astrological Significance' of Archaeoastronomy | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#The Obvious 'Astrological Significance' of Archaeoastronomy |
Categorization | 23 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Categorization |
Confusing sentence | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Confusing sentence |
Refs | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Refs |
20th and 21st centuries | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#20th and 21st centuries |
Personality tests | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Personality tests |
Question on References, statements and some comments | 13 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Question on References, statements and some comments |
List of shady references | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#List of shady references |
Moon and investors | 27 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Moon and investors |
Why "many scientists" and not "scientific community"? | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Why "many scientists" and not "scientific community"? |
Work related injuries | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Work related injuries |
Moon Node & Mars-Vesta | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 8#Moon Node & Mars-Vesta |
Astrology, Science and causality | 17 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Astrology, Science and causality |
Correlation to the personality tests | 11 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Correlation to the personality tests |
Dennis Elwell | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Dennis Elwell |
Serious deterioration of page | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Serious deterioration of page |
Bad Faith | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Bad Faith |
Nature | 21 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Nature |
Peer review suggestions | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Peer review suggestions |
Moon and stock returns (again) | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Moon and stock returns (again) |
Claims | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Claims |
Spiking the orange juice | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Spiking the orange juice |
Bobrick's The Fated Sky | 14 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Bobrick's The Fated Sky |
'Balance' and 'totallydisputed-section' flags | 29 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#'Balance' and 'totallydisputed-section' flags |
Peer reviewed | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Peer reviewed |
Mars effect critiscims | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Mars effect critiscims |
Every possible claim for astrology | 18 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Every possible claim for astrology |
Another bloody thread on a stupid sentence | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Another bloody thread on a stupid sentence |
Further reading | 14 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Further reading |
History section | 13 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#History section |
Chaucer and Shakespeare | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Chaucer and Shakespeare |
Dispute resolution | 13 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Dispute resolution |
Nature study | 10 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Nature study |
Predictions? | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Predictions? |
State of business | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#State of business |
This page is a travesty | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#This page is a travesty |
question about Tycho edit | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#question about Tycho edit |
Wrong references | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Wrong references |
more awkward sentences | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#more awkward sentences |
Effect size studies in astrology | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Effect size studies in astrology |
Constellations | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Constellations |
Carl Sagan | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Carl Sagan |
The offical reading of the giblets | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#The offical reading of the giblets |
Ertel mention. | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Ertel mention. |
Aquiratas, where's your discussion of changes? | 10 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Aquiratas, where's your discussion of changes? |
Changes to subtitles | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Changes to subtitles |
put back reference to alchemy and protoscience | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#put back reference to alchemy and protoscience |
Victor Mansfield | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Victor Mansfield |
Biblical Perspective | 10 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Biblical Perspective |
Jung reference | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Jung reference |
Sad state of affairs | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Sad state of affairs |
Request | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Request |
Ertel | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 9#Ertel |
Section trim | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 10#Section trim |
Scientific proof | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 10#Scientific proof |
Superstition category | 34 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 10#Superstition category |
The divergence | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 10#The divergence |
Uranus, Neptune and Pluto? | 11 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 10#Uranus, Neptune and Pluto? |
Astrology and the liberal arts | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 10#Astrology and the liberal arts |
Cumbersome see also section | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 10#Cumbersome see also section |
Cite for failing to demonstrate | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 10#Cite for failing to demonstrate |
The following statement | 26 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 10#The following statement |
...not always golden | 11 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 10#...not always golden |
Excessive citation? | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 10#Excessive citation? |
Ritual Instrumental Activism | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 10#Ritual Instrumental Activism |
Books Added on Sept 5th, 2006 | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 10#Books Added on Sept 5th, 2006 |
Effect size and similar biased claims | 27 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 10#Effect size and similar biased claims |
category protoscence is inappropriate | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 10#category protoscence is inappropriate |
Capitalization of astrological terms | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 10#Capitalization of astrological terms |
Beginner's question | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 10#Beginner's question |
Vedic Astrology | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 10#Vedic Astrology |
Whoa! | 67 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 33#Whoa! |
site inclusion | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 10#site inclusion |
Supposed correlation | 26 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#Supposed correlation |
NPOV | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#NPOV |
This article is NOT peer reviewed | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#This article is NOT peer reviewed |
External links cleanup | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#External links cleanup |
Stel.la | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#Stel.la |
Objective concerns and areas in which to improve | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#Objective concerns and areas in which to improve |
Classification as a "science" | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#Classification as a "science" |
Question | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#Question |
Further reading | 12 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#Further reading |
pseudoscience? | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#pseudoscience? |
Origins correction | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#Origins correction |
Some correction | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#Some correction |
An impatient but informed??? party............. | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#An impatient but informed??? party............. |
NASA Graphic | 15 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#NASA Graphic |
Nonsense | 17 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#Nonsense |
Geocentric and Heliocentric | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#Geocentric and Heliocentric |
Neutrality With Regards to the Scientific Establishment | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#Neutrality With Regards to the Scientific Establishment |
Credibility | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#Credibility |
Wrong statement in lead | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#Wrong statement in lead |
Pseudosience? | 17 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#Pseudosience? |
More recognized? | 16 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#More recognized? |
mechanism | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#mechanism |
On the bashers of astrology | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#On the bashers of astrology |
Request for Comment: On the increasing popularity of vedic astrology in the West | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#Request for Comment: On the increasing popularity of vedic astrology in the West |
Sigs on comments | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#Sigs on comments |
3rd Opinions | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 11#3rd Opinions |
Issue resolved | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Issue resolved |
Possible Improvements for the Opening Paragraph | 12 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Possible Improvements for the Opening Paragraph |
vedic not suitable for opening paragraph | 14 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#vedic not suitable for opening paragraph |
Move criticism of astrology into own section or article | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Move criticism of astrology into own section or article |
Astrology As A Language | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Astrology As A Language |
Traditions reorganization | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Traditions reorganization |
Category:Astrological factors | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Category:Astrological factors |
Your astrology link --Lundse | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Your astrology link --Lundse |
Massive astrology errors | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Massive astrology errors |
Someone should have studied Classical Greek harder! | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Someone should have studied Classical Greek harder! |
Recent additions | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Recent additions |
Sentence in lead | 21 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Sentence in lead |
Removed Critical appraisal of traditional astrology | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Removed Critical appraisal of traditional astrology |
An open letter on the ongoing state of the article | 26 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#An open letter on the ongoing state of the article |
NPOV (Undue Weight) in overview section | 23 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#NPOV (Undue Weight) in overview section |
Quotes of modern astrologers definition of astrology | 12 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Quotes of modern astrologers definition of astrology |
Revert war in the Research section | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Revert war in the Research section |
Sock puppetry on the astrology page | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Sock puppetry on the astrology page |
Joseph John Dewey, born in 1945 | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Joseph John Dewey, born in 1945 |
Research methods | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Research methods |
Core Beliefs suggestion | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Core Beliefs suggestion |
Biblical references | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Biblical references |
Hermeticism?? | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Hermeticism?? |
Doubtful etymology | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Doubtful etymology |
definition of astrology: phrasing and implication | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#definition of astrology: phrasing and implication |
Hermetism template | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Hermetism template |
Invitation to CfD Category:Pseudoskeptic Target Discussion | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Invitation to CfD Category:Pseudoskeptic Target Discussion |
Are there any citations for this babble?? | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Are there any citations for this babble?? |
Astrology a Pseudoscience? | 27 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Astrology a Pseudoscience? |
Interstellar travel | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Interstellar travel |
Bias | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Bias |
Ambiguous pronoun | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Ambiguous pronoun |
Cosmic Latte's removal of "claim" | 19 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 12#Cosmic Latte's removal of "claim" |
Opening paragraph | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Opening paragraph |
Wikipedia needs a whole new family of articles discussing Season of birth | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Wikipedia needs a whole new family of articles discussing Season of birth |
Extensive list of people by astrological sign from [What was done] | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Extensive list of people by astrological sign from [What was done] |
Scientists | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Scientists |
Redirect from "Creation Astronomy" | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Redirect from "Creation Astronomy" |
Scientific Journals dealing with astrology | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Scientific Journals dealing with astrology |
Astrology and economics | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Astrology and economics |
Bias against astrology | 17 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Bias against astrology |
Indian astrology | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Indian astrology |
WikiProject on countering systemic bias | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#WikiProject on countering systemic bias |
Evaluation of Astrology (Astrology and Science Section) | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Evaluation of Astrology (Astrology and Science Section) |
This is not the "Astrology in the US" article | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#This is not the "Astrology in the US" article |
Astrology as a reality of postmodern society | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Astrology as a reality of postmodern society |
Biblical commentary | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Biblical commentary |
Agreement to prevent injury | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Agreement to prevent injury |
Stand up for science | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Stand up for science |
RfC: Wording of statement about scientific opinion | 30 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#RfC: Wording of statement about scientific opinion |
Science vs astrology statement and related citations | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Science vs astrology statement and related citations |
Statement of 186 and Paul Feyerabend's rebuttal | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Statement of 186 and Paul Feyerabend's rebuttal |
Compromise proposal on science vs. astrology | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Compromise proposal on science vs. astrology |
The Lede | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#The Lede |
Magi Astrology | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Magi Astrology |
Categorization | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Categorization |
The scientific community? | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#The scientific community? |
Slightly odd-sounding sentence | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Slightly odd-sounding sentence |
Dr. Richard Tarnas | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Dr. Richard Tarnas |
If and how to mention Vedic/Eastern views | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#If and how to mention Vedic/Eastern views |
Sanskrit terminology for astrology | 14 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Sanskrit terminology for astrology |
Western astrology | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Western astrology |
Lead | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Lead |
Of horoscopes and hot sauce | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Of horoscopes and hot sauce |
Psychology | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Psychology |
Verb tense and pipelink | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Verb tense and pipelink |
Layout | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Layout |
Influence on global warming? | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Influence on global warming? |
The topic of Face reading is created based on the following.... | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#The topic of Face reading is created based on the following.... |
The relationship of the topic with science.... | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#The relationship of the topic with science.... |
Physionomics - new area...??? | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Physionomics - new area...??? |
Science and Engineering Indicators 2006 cited in the lead | 10 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 13#Science and Engineering Indicators 2006 cited in the lead |
When are calling the modern era? | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 14#When are calling the modern era? |
Could pseudosciences become sciences? | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 14#Could pseudosciences become sciences? |
Do astrologers *believe* that astrology affects humans? -or claim it? -or both? | 18 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 14#Do astrologers *believe* that astrology affects humans? -or claim it? -or both? |
Predictive Astrology - Inaccurate | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 14#Predictive Astrology - Inaccurate |
Hyperdimensional Astrology | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 14#Hyperdimensional Astrology |
'pseudoscience' in first line | 51 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 14#'pseudoscience' in first line |
Proposed introduction - does it have consensus or is it breaking policy? | 103 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 15#Proposed introduction - does it have consensus or is it breaking policy? |
incoherent lead | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 14#incoherent lead |
Court order | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 14#Court order |
Proposal to split off the Scientific criticism of astrology | 15 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 14#Proposal to split off the Scientific criticism of astrology |
ironically not the stars | 62 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 14#ironically not the stars |
predictive/determinative | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 14#predictive/determinative |
"Stars" as a general or specific term? | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 15#"Stars" as a general or specific term? |
Bravo! | 12 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 15#Bravo! |
Where is Dean's Time Twin Study? | 13 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 16#Where is Dean's Time Twin Study? |
Remove straw man and authoritarian arguments | 24 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 15#Remove straw man and authoritarian arguments |
Proposal | 63 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 16#Proposal |
Pseudo-rationality of scientific sceptics | 48 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 15#Pseudo-rationality of scientific sceptics |
First things first | 29 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 16#First things first |
Divhide discussions | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 16#Divhide discussions |
Rawhide diaries | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 16#Rawhide diaries |
Important reading for everyone here | 29 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 16#Important reading for everyone here |
Moving towards consensus | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 16#Moving towards consensus |
Did somebody say "offsite coordination"? | 15 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 16#Did somebody say "offsite coordination"? |
The arbitration committee | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 16#The arbitration committee |
Dubious | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 16#Dubious |
Compromise susgestion | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 16#Compromise susgestion |
AN/I | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 16#AN/I |
Astrology bannings | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 17#Astrology bannings |
Can we save some of the pro-astrology contributions? | 19 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 16#Can we save some of the pro-astrology contributions? |
We're exactly nowhere, so back to basics | 19 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 17#We're exactly nowhere, so back to basics |
17 edits, five users, less than 24 hours | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 17#17 edits, five users, less than 24 hours |
References needed | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 17#References needed |
Proposed 29 March edits from Peter S Strempel - now moved to workpage for editing and discussion | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 17#Proposed 29 March edits from Peter S Strempel - now moved to workpage for editing and discussion |
Astrology as belief | 12 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 17#Astrology as belief |
Science as a matter of law | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 17#Science as a matter of law |
Education section | 24 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 17#Education section |
Apology | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 17#Apology |
Astrology practice and theory discussed | 35 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 17#Astrology practice and theory discussed |
Pejorative intent | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 17#Pejorative intent |
Major edit now made | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 17#Major edit now made |
Does Tyson's opinion add to the page? | 29 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 17#Does Tyson's opinion add to the page? |
Sections | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 17#Sections |
Notable astrologers | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 17#Notable astrologers |
Revision of Criticism | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 17#Revision of Criticism |
Edit request from P.Ganakan, 22 April 2011 | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 17#Edit request from P.Ganakan, 22 April 2011 |
Edit request from 78.2.93.209, 24 April 2011 | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 18#Edit request from 78.2.93.209, 24 April 2011 |
This WP entry is not working. A suggestion for a new approach. | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 17#This WP entry is not working. A suggestion for a new approach. |
definiton of astrology | 56 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 18#definiton of astrology |
Edit request from Treer, 5 July 2011 | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 17#Edit request from Treer, 5 July 2011 |
Layout | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 18#Layout |
Stop! This is an encyclopaedia, not a debating society | 26 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 18#Stop! This is an encyclopaedia, not a debating society |
Let's Vote on Divination | 37 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 18#Let's Vote on Divination |
'Psychology' as a part of astrology. | 28 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 19#'Psychology' as a part of astrology. |
Redirecting focus on content | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 18#Redirecting focus on content |
Clarifying the purpose of this article, and the correct focus of approach towards content | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 18#Clarifying the purpose of this article, and the correct focus of approach towards content |
Recent straw poll | 11 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 19#Recent straw poll |
References for the pseudo-science comments in the lede | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 19#References for the pseudo-science comments in the lede |
Rethinking the structure | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 19#Rethinking the structure |
Remaining problems with the lede | 22 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 19#Remaining problems with the lede |
Bibliography and external links | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 19#Bibliography and external links |
Divination | 14 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 19#Divination |
Sub-pages to avoid disputes? | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 19#Sub-pages to avoid disputes? |
Reverting Makesense64 edits due to total lack of consultation and not working with other editors | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 19#Reverting Makesense64 edits due to total lack of consultation and not working with other editors |
Astrological education section | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 19#Astrological education section |
Updated Core Principles section | 11 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 19#Updated Core Principles section |
Vote to support or debate Wikipedia guidelines and rulings | 10 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 19#Vote to support or debate Wikipedia guidelines and rulings |
Image Changes | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 19#Image Changes |
Obvious errors | 15 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 19#Obvious errors |
Notable personalities | 15 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Notable personalities |
Censorship | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 19#Censorship |
Proposed deletion of Astrology history articles | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 19#Proposed deletion of Astrology history articles |
Placement of "not in citation" tags in lede | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 19#Placement of "not in citation" tags in lede |
Core pinciples | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 19#Core pinciples |
Astrological techniques and practices | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Astrological techniques and practices |
Preferred spelling for articles | 16 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Preferred spelling for articles |
Research | 23 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Research |
History: Contemporary changes: Western | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#History: Contemporary changes: Western |
Lede: Para 2 Origins of the Revival | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Lede: Para 2 Origins of the Revival |
Templates on top | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Templates on top |
Refuted | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Refuted |
Quote: "Western astrologers don’t deal with stars" | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Quote: "Western astrologers don’t deal with stars" |
Research updated | 22 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Research updated |
Humanist article | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Humanist article |
Astrology & Culture - J K Rowling et al | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Astrology & Culture - J K Rowling et al |
Proposed revision to Etymology section & new 'Notes' section | 19 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Proposed revision to Etymology section & new 'Notes' section |
Some general points | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Some general points |
Mechanisms update | 10 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Mechanisms update |
Core principles | 16 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Core principles |
Proposal for the history section | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Proposal for the history section |
Other cultural systems of astrology | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Other cultural systems of astrology |
Astrological techniques and practices? | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Astrological techniques and practices? |
Astrology and science? | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Astrology and science? |
Principles | 12 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Principles |
Basic tenets of astrology | 10 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 20#Basic tenets of astrology |
The language convention of this page | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 21#The language convention of this page |
Blind or Double-Blind? | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 21#Blind or Double-Blind? |
please explain | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 21#please explain |
Carlson review | 16 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 21#Carlson review |
Request for comment on sourcing | 10 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 21#Request for comment on sourcing |
Original Research | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 21#Original Research |
More specific RfC on sourcing in research section. | 35 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 24#More specific RfC on sourcing in research section. |
Reminder of policy | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 21#Reminder of policy |
Achieving Neutrality | 10 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 21#Achieving Neutrality |
Tags | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 21#Tags |
This article appears not to be about 'astrology' | 29 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 21#This article appears not to be about 'astrology' |
synchonicity | 22 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 21#synchonicity |
Joan Quigley | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 21#Joan Quigley |
Recent "Obstacles to research" and "Mechanisms" Edits | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 21#Recent "Obstacles to research" and "Mechanisms" Edits |
Comments on proposal | 45 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 21#Comments on proposal |
Mechanisms review – proposed amendment for 1st part on Humanist and Sagan references | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 22#Mechanisms review – proposed amendment for 1st part on Humanist and Sagan references |
Editing principles | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 21#Editing principles |
Gauquelin's research | 52 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 23#Gauquelin's research |
Towards consensus | 46 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 24#Towards consensus |
Change proposals | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 21#Change proposals |
Time for formal request for Arbitration Enforcement? | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 21#Time for formal request for Arbitration Enforcement? |
Sagan | 10 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 24#Sagan |
SPA edits nearing vandalism | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 21#SPA edits nearing vandalism |
Lede | 19 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 21#Lede |
Etymology section | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 22#Etymology section |
Core Principles section | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 22#Core Principles section |
Pseudoscience | 31 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 23#Pseudoscience |
Same problems at Psychological astrology | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 22#Same problems at Psychological astrology |
Help with the lead | 11 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 22#Help with the lead |
Help with cosmic cybernetics | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 22#Help with cosmic cybernetics |
Major editing without discussion | 76 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 22#Major editing without discussion |
Reputable astrologers | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 22#Reputable astrologers |
Some math | 15 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 22#Some math |
main article reverts with no talk page discussion | 24 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 22#main article reverts with no talk page discussion |
Lack of subject matter expertise | 72 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 22#Lack of subject matter expertise |
New 'Varieties of Astrology' section needs editorial attention | 17 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 23#New 'Varieties of Astrology' section needs editorial attention |
New to the Article | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 23#New to the Article |
Top of the page notice | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 23#Top of the page notice |
Scientific criticism is not scientific research | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 23#Scientific criticism is not scientific research |
Lead | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 23#Lead |
Regarding the "pseudoscience" reference in the lead | 30 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 23#Regarding the "pseudoscience" reference in the lead |
Looks like that P-word is the only thing that really matters here | 55 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 24#Looks like that P-word is the only thing that really matters here |
Bibliography? | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 23#Bibliography? |
This addition will help the lede to define the subject effectively | 38 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 23#This addition will help the lede to define the subject effectively |
Template:Ast Box no white space/ margin | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 24#Template:Ast Box no white space/ margin |
What is more important? | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 24#What is more important? |
Merge 2 Templates? | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 24#Merge 2 Templates? |
Western Astrology Duplicate Sentence | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 24#Western Astrology Duplicate Sentence |
Criticism of Carlson claims | 18 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 24#Criticism of Carlson claims |
Full protection | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 24#Full protection |
Request for comment | 54 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 25#Request for comment |
Next step? | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 24#Next step? |
Outstanding issues | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 24#Outstanding issues |
Page unprotected | 14 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 24#Page unprotected |
/* Core principles | 28 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 25#/* Core principles |
Correlation as a source. Again. | 13 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 25#Correlation as a source. Again. |
Avoiding protection | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 25#Avoiding protection |
Academic research in astrology / online links suggestions | 19 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 25#Academic research in astrology / online links suggestions |
Indian and southwest Asian astrology | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 25#Indian and southwest Asian astrology |
Lead | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 25#Lead |
"planetary object" | 15 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 25#"planetary object" |
Lead again | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 25#Lead again |
Astrology as a science | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 25#Astrology as a science |
Pseudoscience again again. | 33 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 25#Pseudoscience again again. |
There are issues to resolve before putting the proposed text to a vote | 30 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 25#There are issues to resolve before putting the proposed text to a vote |
RFC on change to pseudoscience summary in lede | 60 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 26#RFC on change to pseudoscience summary in lede |
Why are editors of this page not adhering to the core policies of WP? | 13 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 26#Why are editors of this page not adhering to the core policies of WP? |
Astrologers' definition of planet more historical? | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 25#Astrologers' definition of planet more historical? |
Attribute | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 26#Attribute |
The editorial approach to this page should be recognised for the joke it has become | 33 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 26#The editorial approach to this page should be recognised for the joke it has become |
Tempest in a teapot | 21 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 26#Tempest in a teapot |
Kepler | 10 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 26#Kepler |
a more serious approach to editing this article | 36 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 27#a more serious approach to editing this article |
"Astrology and Science" website | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 26#"Astrology and Science" website |
NPOV in the "modern scientific appraisal" section and the lede | 14 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 26#NPOV in the "modern scientific appraisal" section and the lede |
Scanned source | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 27#Scanned source |
astrology "the oldest of the sciences" | 17 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 27#astrology "the oldest of the sciences" |
Protected | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 27#Protected |
celestial vs planetary | 13 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 27#celestial vs planetary |
"most astrologers make claims that the position of all the planets must be taken into account" | 21 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 27#"most astrologers make claims that the position of all the planets must be taken into account" |
Influential/Non-influential Dichotomy | 16 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 27#Influential/Non-influential Dichotomy |
Dubious weight - Education section | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 27#Dubious weight - Education section |
Lede change based upon Rfc | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 27#Lede change based upon Rfc |
Cartoon image | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 27#Cartoon image |
"astrologers prefer not to attempt to explain astrology" | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 27#"astrologers prefer not to attempt to explain astrology" |
Theodor Adorno's criticism of Sun sign astrology | 14 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 27#Theodor Adorno's criticism of Sun sign astrology |
The Wikipedia approach fails for this subject | 28 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 27#The Wikipedia approach fails for this subject |
Appraising the content of the ‘Modern scientific appraisal’ section | 25 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 27#Appraising the content of the ‘Modern scientific appraisal’ section |
Suggested re-arrangement of text for intro to Modern Scientific appraisal section | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 27#Suggested re-arrangement of text for intro to Modern Scientific appraisal section |
Mundane Astrology | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 28#Mundane Astrology |
Popper ref | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 28#Popper ref |
Falsifiability | 33 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 28#Falsifiability |
Theological criticism | 25 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 28#Theological criticism |
Poorly referenced sections | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 28#Poorly referenced sections |
An historian of science's report that the info given in the criticisms section of this article is "seriously wrong" | 30 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 28#An historian of science's report that the info given in the criticisms section of this article is "seriously wrong" |
Move precesssion explanation into the 'world traditions' section, and rename that section 'Divergence of systems' | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 28#Move precesssion explanation into the 'world traditions' section, and rename that section 'Divergence of systems' |
Arbitration Enforcement | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 28#Arbitration Enforcement |
20th and 21st century | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 28#20th and 21st century |
The Hartmann, Reuter and Nyborg paper - ref 59 | 26 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 28#The Hartmann, Reuter and Nyborg paper - ref 59 |
Modern | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 28#Modern |
Core principles | 30 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 28#Core principles |
Scientific appraisal | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 28#Scientific appraisal |
"Correlation" and reliable sources and "Other astrologers prefer not to attempt to explain astrology." | 26 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 28#"Correlation" and reliable sources and "Other astrologers prefer not to attempt to explain astrology." |
Etymology section | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 29#Etymology section |
Western astrology tradition | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 29#Western astrology tradition |
Brockbank on astrological methodology and empirical science | 17 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 29#Brockbank on astrological methodology and empirical science |
Status as a science in India | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 29#Status as a science in India |
"Vedic astrology -- critically examined" | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 29#"Vedic astrology -- critically examined" |
another Hindu reference sourced to astrologer James Braha | 10 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 29#another Hindu reference sourced to astrologer James Braha |
"astronomical phenomena predict or cause events in the human world" | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 29#"astronomical phenomena predict or cause events in the human world" |
Merge | 15 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 29#Merge |
Merge in Astrologer | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 29#Merge in Astrologer |
Geoffrey Dean and Ivan W. Kelly Is Astrology Relevant to Consciousness and Psi? | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 29#Geoffrey Dean and Ivan W. Kelly Is Astrology Relevant to Consciousness and Psi? |
To me 'Ibn Qayyim Al-Jawziyya' is an absolute dunce at Astrology | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 29#To me 'Ibn Qayyim Al-Jawziyya' is an absolute dunce at Astrology |
Merge? | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 29#Merge? |
Cognitive Bias | 33 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 29#Cognitive Bias |
The lead | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 29#The lead |
Proposed link: Astrology and Science | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 29#Proposed link: Astrology and Science |
Contentious edit | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 29#Contentious edit |
Pseudo-science or proto-science? | 35 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 29#Pseudo-science or proto-science? |
Recent sourcing | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 29#Recent sourcing |
Mediaeval literature | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 29#Mediaeval literature |
Undiscussed removal of fully-cited materials from History | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#Undiscussed removal of fully-cited materials from History |
When astrology and astronomy overlapped | 18 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#When astrology and astronomy overlapped |
Copy-editing 'Scientific appraisal' | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#Copy-editing 'Scientific appraisal' |
Indian material deleted from Omen article | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#Indian material deleted from Omen article |
"and subsequent controlled studies failed to confirm its predictive value" | 26 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#"and subsequent controlled studies failed to confirm its predictive value" |
"Where astrology has made falsifiable predictions, it has been falsified." | 18 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#"Where astrology has made falsifiable predictions, it has been falsified." |
astrology and divination | 28 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#astrology and divination |
Interpretation of cited sources | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#Interpretation of cited sources |
GA Review | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#GA Review |
Dating of Earliest Astrologies | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#Dating of Earliest Astrologies |
History of Astrology and Bias Against Astrology | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#History of Astrology and Bias Against Astrology |
Astrology Table/Quick facts | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#Astrology Table/Quick facts |
:249 and :424 | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#:249 and :424 |
Deleted text on Precession of the Equinoxes (moved from GA page) | 18 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#Deleted text on Precession of the Equinoxes (moved from GA page) |
Dissent | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#Dissent |
This is a biased article and is totally erroneous in the proof for astrology | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#This is a biased article and is totally erroneous in the proof for astrology |
Sectioning off the historical objections | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#Sectioning off the historical objections |
Sentence needs to be reworded | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#Sentence needs to be reworded |
footnote 7 link re falsifiability | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#footnote 7 link re falsifiability |
Proposal for section on cosmic cybernetics | 24 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#Proposal for section on cosmic cybernetics |
New lead section | 14 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#New lead section |
Lead | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#Lead |
Origins of Hindu astrology | 10 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#Origins of Hindu astrology |
Articles for astrological signs | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 30#Articles for astrological signs |
Additions to theological viewpoints | 7 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Additions to theological viewpoints |
Theory of Personality Types | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Theory of Personality Types |
Lead | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Lead |
Contested Deletion of Best Selling Novel on Astrology in Literature | 21 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Contested Deletion of Best Selling Novel on Astrology in Literature |
Sumerians not mentioned... | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Sumerians not mentioned... |
Dropping the 'pseudoscience' - Scientism bias. | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Dropping the 'pseudoscience' - Scientism bias. |
Mediæval should be updated to Medieval | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Mediæval should be updated to Medieval |
Chaldean wisdom | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Chaldean wisdom |
Arabic Renaissance | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Arabic Renaissance |
Pseudoscience in first sentence as definition | 80 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Pseudoscience in first sentence as definition |
Problems with the third paragraph | 10 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Problems with the third paragraph |
Lead | 48 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Lead 2 |
"Pseudoscientific divination" | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#"Pseudoscientific divination" |
External links modified | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#External links modified |
Scientific analysis and criticism | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Scientific analysis and criticism |
Arabian Astrology Table | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Arabian Astrology Table |
"With the onset of the scientific revolution astrology was called into question" | 10 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#"With the onset of the scientific revolution astrology was called into question" |
External links modified | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#External links modified 2 |
repetition in astrology article | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#repetition in astrology article |
With the onset of the scientific revolution astrology was called into question | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#With the onset of the scientific revolution astrology was called into question |
Astrology is not what this article talks about. | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Astrology is not what this article talks about. |
Zodiac lucky numbers | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Zodiac lucky numbers |
New Section | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#New Section |
Request for external link - Renaissance Astrology | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Request for external link - Renaissance Astrology |
Source 13 is a dead link. | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Source 13 is a dead link. |
Fronting the pseudoscientific aspect of astrology | 36 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Fronting the pseudoscientific aspect of astrology |
Factual accuracy | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Factual accuracy |
Threat of vandalism as a reason to not put PS near the top of the lede | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Threat of vandalism as a reason to not put PS near the top of the lede |
"Pseudoscience" | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#"Pseudoscience" |
Effectiveness | 8 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Effectiveness |
Missing link to the Japanese article on the side bar | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 31#Missing link to the Japanese article on the side bar |
Hans Eysenck | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Hans Eysenck |
Recent lead changes | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Recent lead changes |
Pseudoscience: Anachronistic / Non-Neutral Terminology | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Pseudoscience: Anachronistic / Non-Neutral Terminology |
Please add link to "See also" | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Please add link to "See also" |
Categorization... Not Pseudoscience? | 32 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Categorization... Not Pseudoscience? |
Addition to astrology article | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Addition to astrology article |
"Astrologaster" listed at Redirects for discussion | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#"Astrologaster" listed at Redirects for discussion |
Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 25 March 2020 | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 25 March 2020 |
Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 20 April 2020 | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 20 April 2020 |
Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 26 April 2020 | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 26 April 2020 |
Heliocentric astrology | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Heliocentric astrology |
First Sentence | 17 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#First Sentence |
Decapitalize 'Ancient'? | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Decapitalize 'Ancient'? |
Someone needs to clean up the provocative wording in this article. | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Someone needs to clean up the provocative wording in this article. |
Scientific analysis and criticism | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Scientific analysis and criticism |
Fix footnote 8 | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Fix footnote 8 |
Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 21 October 2020 | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 21 October 2020 |
Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 31 October 2020 | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 31 October 2020 |
"divine" | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#"divine" |
First sentence should include widely considered to be | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#First sentence should include widely considered to be |
Astrology page removal | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Astrology page removal |
Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 21 April 2021 | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 21 April 2021 |
Addition of a comma or colon | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Addition of a comma or colon |
the word divine and claims which are repetitive | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#the word divine and claims which are repetitive |
Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 17 July 2021 | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 17 July 2021 |
Opening sentence | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Opening sentence |
Pseudoscientific and disproven? | 14 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Pseudoscientific and disproven? |
Astrology-related articles being discussed for deletion | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Astrology-related articles being discussed for deletion |
Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 2 December 2021 | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 2 December 2021 |
Astrology and "pseudo-science" | 6 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Astrology and "pseudo-science" |
Celestial influence | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Celestial influence |
Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 18 February 2022 | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 18 February 2022 |
WP:NPOV, on the pseudoscience | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#WP:NPOV, on the pseudoscience |
Stronger statement in lead on Western Astrology lacking empirical credibility needed | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Stronger statement in lead on Western Astrology lacking empirical credibility needed |
Astrology and pseudoscience | 32 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 33#Astrology and pseudoscience |
Cultural astronomy | 50 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 33#Cultural astronomy |
Whoa! | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 32#Whoa! |
Astrology versus astronomy | 46 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 34#Astrology versus astronomy |
Astrology as divination | 3 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 33#Astrology as divination |
Lede revision | 113 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 34#Lede revision |
Structure of article | 12 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 36#Structure of article |
Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 11 June 2022 | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 34#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 11 June 2022 |
Final final wordsmithing | 9 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 35#Final final wordsmithing |
Request for comments: Lead paragraph | 132 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 35#Request for comments: Lead paragraph |
Arab World or Islamic World? | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 35#Arab World or Islamic World? |
RfC about short description | 89 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 36#RfC about short description |
Merge Astrology, Western Astrology, Zodiac, History of Astrology? | 11 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 35#Merge Astrology, Western Astrology, Zodiac, History of Astrology? |
Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 16 November 2022 | 2 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 36#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 16 November 2022 |
Please add to literature list, for a more balanced overview | 1 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 36#Please add to literature list, for a more balanced overview |
Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 19 January 2023 | 4 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 36#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 19 January 2023 |
Since When Has It Been Pseudoscience? | 22 | Talk:Astrology#Since When Has It Been Pseudoscience? |
Neutrality of "Theological viewpoints" | 5 | Talk:Astrology/Archive 36#Neutrality of "Theological viewpoints" |
Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 4 September 2023 | 2 | Talk:Astrology#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 4 September 2023 |
Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 8 October 2023 | 2 | Talk:Astrology#Extended-confirmed-protected edit request on 8 October 2023 |
Detractors, competitors and skeptics | 20 | Talk:Astrology#Detractors, competitors and skeptics |